She’s got a gentle spot for suspects headed for onerous time, critics cost.
Lefty Brooklyn Criminal Court Judge Janice Robinson has repeatedly reduce accused criminals unfastened with no or minimal bail, including in attempted-murder instances — refusing to facet with prosecutors’ suggestions in these situations even once, a damning evaluation by The Post has discovered.
Since not too long ago shifting over from the civil bench, Robinson, the niece of a longtime Democrat state lawmaker, has persistently gone straightforward on many defendants, according to an examination of more than a dozen of her legal instances.
Brooklyn Criminal Court Judge Janice Robinson has failed to facet with prosecutors on bail in more than a dozen latest instances. Youtube/Judge Janice Robinson
Of these 13 instances, eight accused criminals walked out of courtroom with no bail — including two charged with tried homicide, among them a minor who already had a pending attempted-murder rap against him. The other 5 defendants had bail set — but it was nicely under what the DA’s workplace requested, information present.
“She’s never set bail over $10,000, and that was on an attempted murder, which means you walk for a lousy 10% — a $1,000 — partially secured bond backed by nothing,” a pissed off law-enforcement supply instructed The Post.
Prosecutors needed Nayshawn Wilkinson held with out bail for tried homicide. The decide set $5,000, which he posted. Obtained by NY Post, Obtained by NY Post
It is outrageous to refuse “to set meaningful bail on defendants with this many open cases — shooters, blatant recidivists who have shown they will shoot, steal and do violence no matter how many bites at the apple they get,” the supply said.
The state Office of Court Administration, which speaks for judges in the state, did not reply to several Post requests for remark on Robinson’s behalf.
Nearly all of the defendants let loose by Robinson in the reviewed instances have return dates to courtroom later in the yr, so it is not yet recognized if any will take benefit of their comfortable conditions and blow off their mandated appearances.
But very few would seemingly be on the streets if prosecutors had gotten the bail circumstances they requested for.
Robinson, the Brooklyn-born daughter of Jamaican immigrants, was elected to the bench in 2024 and took a seat in the borough’s civil courtroom Jan. 1, 2025, according to reports.
Sunny Demitro had 10 open instances when he was charged with automobile theft. The decide set $5,000 bail, which he posted.. Obtained by NY Post, Obtained by NY Post
She is the niece of Nick Perry, a Democrat who served in the state Assembly practically 30 years representing elements of East Flatbush, Canarsie and Brownsville and later served briefly as US ambassador to Jamaica.
Robinson graduated from Hofstra University and earned a legislation diploma from American University. She is a member of Alpha Kappa Alpha, the first black sorority, and spent the first 20 years of her authorized profession as a lawyer for insurance coverage firms before turning to politics.
After serving as a civil courtroom decide, she was not too long ago transferred to the legal bench.
Robinson joined the civil bench last yr before shifting to legal courtroom this yr. Michael Nagle
Among the instances reviewed by The Post is the arrest of 19-year-old accused tried assassin Nayshawn WIlkinson.
The teen was in courtroom Aug 4 when the DA’s workplace requested that he be despatched to Rikers with out bail. Wilkinson was charged with tried homicide for allegedly firing a gun into a busy Brooklyn intersection. Robinson granted him $5,000 bail or a $10,000 bond, which he later posted.
Jonathan Morris, 21, was also dealing with an attempted-murder cost when he went before Robinson on two instances, which also included weapons possession. Prosecutors needed him held on $250,000 money bail, but the decide set the mark at $5,000 in one case — and $1 on the other, sources said.
Jonathan Morris was charged with tried homicide but still launched on low bail by Judge Robinson. Obtained by NY Post, Obtained by NY Post
In another case, Brooklyn prosecutors requested for bail of $100,000 money or a $500,000 bond for Omar Perry, 44, who charged with theft and weapons possession for stealing a mobile phone from a bus passenger and threatening to kill them while wielding a hammer.
Robinson instead let Perry stroll with out bail but under supervision Aug. 3.
She did the same in the case of Sunny Demitro, 31, who has at least 10 open instances and was nabbed June 17 on prices that he stole a automobile and fled the scene of a hit and run accident. Robinson let him go on supervised launch despite the DA asking for $25,000 money or a $50,000 bond.
Demitro, who confronted 38 prices in the case, was arrested over a new grand larceny incident Aug. 8, when a completely different decide set his bail at $5,000 or $10,000, which he posted.
Humberto Ortiz was another accused repeat offender who benefited by going before Robinson Obtained by NY Post, Obtained by NY Post
On Aug. 3, Robinson launched 32-year-old Elijah Guy with out bail despite the DA’s workplace asking he be held on $50,000 money or a bond of up to $100,000 on prices that he pulled a gun and fired two pictures at a 66-year-old man after a dispute.
Guy was also charged with another assault case stemming from a July 31 incident.
In addition, Robinson ordered Blackman Devon, 36, launched with out bail Aug. 6 after he was allegedly nabbed with a loaded gun and felony drug prices two days earlier. Prosecutors requested for $100,000 money bail.
In yet another case, Watson Barthelemy went before the decide the same day dealing with theft, assault and theft prices — with two open instances, including a felony assault rap, already hanging over him.
Barthelemy, 29, had been previosly locked up at Rikers Island on a public lewdness and harassment cost after another decide set his bail at $10,000 over $25,000, which he posted July 11.
When he went before Robinson on the new theft cost, Brooklyn prosecutors requested that he be held on $100,000 money or a $200,000 bond, but the decide launched him with out bail.
In another case, Humberto Ortiz, 48, who has seven open instances, was charged with grand larceny, housebreaking, possession of stolen property and possession of burglar instruments July 21 but launched with out bail by Robinson — despite a request by the DA that he be held on $25,000 money bail or a $50,000 bond.
Artcle credit score and Source hyperlink